I originally received this Point Horror anthology as a birthday gift from one of my best friends, way back when I was 11 or 12. I read it for the first time that summer and revisited it again and again. While none of the tales ever really scared me, even as a kid, they were thrilling and fun and infinitely re-readable. So I thought now, on my 30th birthday, I’d revisit the collection and give it a proper review. This collection is filled with authors who were super popular in the 90s, so there’s also an incredibly high nostalgia value here for those of us who lived through that time.
“Collect Call”-Christopher Pike
“Collect Call” is actually divided into two parts; one begins the compilation, the other appears later on. This is a fun tale that plays with time and destiny – two girls are in love with the same dangerous boy, but which one will be his victim and which one will enact the other’s revenge?
I originally loved this story because of its depiction of an underwater town – flooded to create a nearby dam. That concept always fascinated me as a kid. The story itself is one of retribution from beyond the grave. Nothing fancy or too original, but fun all the same.
“The Guiccioli Minature”-Jay Bennett
This one is one of the best written in the collection but doesn’t really fit well with the other stories, being much quieter and more understated.
“Blood Kiss”-D. E. Athkins
I thought this vampire story was oh-so-romantic when I was growing up. Now that the media has been oversaturated by romantic vampires, I’m a little less in to it, but it’s still worth a read.
“A Little Taste of Death”-Patricia Windsor
This one, though one of the more original entries, has never been one of my favorites. The “never take candy from a stranger” saying is hounded home here, when a girl finds herself mixed up with a group of other teens who all took candy from the same man when they were kids. These teens are now turning up dead.
“The Doll”-Carol Ellis
I always forget about this story, which is a shame, because, while not original, it’s still a pretty good entry into the “killer doll” subgenre. Nothing seasoned horror fans haven’t seen before, but for kids who may be less familiar with Chucky, Annabelle, and their ilk, it’s a good diving in point for the subgenre.
“House of Horrors”-J. B. Stamper
A teen stays after-hours in a wax museum of horrors. Haunted/deadly wax museums are another popular subgenre, and this is another fun jumping off point for kids not yet familiar with the “House of Wax” films, “Wax Mask,” or anything similar. It’s also a genuinely fun story, even for those of us familiar with the course it takes.
“Where the Deer Are”-Caroline Cooney
This, the suspense thriller, Mummy (received as a gift from the same friend on the same birthday), and (obviously for those of us in the 90s) The Face on the Milk Carton were my introductions to Caroline Cooney. “Where the Deer Are” was definitely the strangest of those initial reads, but it’s also the only one of those three that has really stuck with me over the years.
“The Spell”-R. L. Stine
I stand by what I’ve said before. R. L. Stine is comfort food horror. You can always count on him for a good time, and this story is no exception.
“Dedicated to the One I Love”-Diane Hoh
Three best friends are all unknowingly dating the same boy and accidentally kill him after finding out and attempting revenge. This one has I Know What You Did Last Summer vibes, mixed with the supernatural. It’s one of the most fun entries in the collection, although I’m not sure if I would have appreciated it as much had I read it for the first time as an adult.
This one might have been my favorite back in the day. It’s a fun tale of a girl going up against a serial killer, and I must have read it a million times as a teen. While the computer aspect of it is so out of date today, it otherwise still holds up.
A story of the gift of life conquering death, this one is one of the most memorable, if not one of the best in the collection. Plus, it has cats. I love cats.
“The Boy Next Door”-Ellen Emerson White
I’ve seen this story in other anthologies as well, for good reason. The story of a girl facing off a dangerous acquaintance in an ice cream parlor after hours is one of the best written in the collection and features a neat twist.
Overall, this collection holds up to adult re-reading. It’s nothing incredibly special, but a good way to kill a few hours. The stories, for the most part, are fun, quick reads, and I highly recommend for both current teens looking for an introduction to the horror genre, as well as for people of my generation, who want to take a nostalgic trip back to their teens.